Vaccine Alarmism

Vaccine Alarmism

Want to receive by email in the morning? Sign up here.

If you are a regular reader of this newspaper, then perhaps you are familiar Idea of ​​Commentary Alarm. It goes something like this:

Coronavirus vaccines are not 100 percent effective. Vaccinated people can still be contagious. And virus variants can spoil everything. So do not change your behavior even if you get a shot.

Much of this message has some basis in truth, but it is fundamentally misleading. Proofs so far A full dose of the vaccine suggests – with a reasonable waiting period after the second shot – Kovid-19 effectively eliminates the risk of death, Almost eliminates the risk of hospitalization and significantly reduces a person’s ability to infect someone else. This is also true of new variants of the virus.

Still the alarm keeps ringing. And now we’re looking at its real-world cost: Many people do not want to receive the vaccine partly because it seems so ineffective.

About one third of the US Army members Vaccine shots are denied. When shots first became available to Ohio nursing-home workers, about 60 percent Said that someone. Some nba stars Are careful Appearing in public-services advertisements encouraging vaccination.

Nationwide, nearly half of Americans refuse a shot if offered one immediately, Election suggestion. Vaccination is doubtful even higher Among black and Hispanic people, white people without college degrees, registered Republicans, and low-income households.

Kate Grabowski, an epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins, told me that she had heard from relatives about her friends and co-workers that they did not choose the shot because they kept hearing that they could still get Kovid and give it to others Are – and will still be required to wear masks and social distances. “What’s it?” He said describing their attitude.

A message from experts, Grabowski said, “is being misinterpreted. He is on us. We are clearly doing something wrong.”

“Our discussion about vaccines has been poor, poor indeed,” Dr. Mage Kevic, A virologist, told me. “As scientists we need to be more careful about what we say and how it can be understood by the public.”

Many academic experts – and, yes, journalists too – are instinctively skeptical and cautious. This instinct has brought public messages about vaccines. to emphasize Uncertainty and possible future bad news.

To take an example: Early research trials with Modern and Pfizer Vaccine did not study whether a vaccinated person could infect and infect another person. But accumulated scientific evidence suggests that the probability that a vaccinated person may infect someone else with a severe case of Kovid is very low. (A mild case is effectively the common cold.) You may not know that much of public discussion.

Dr. of the University of Minnesota Rebecca Wurtz said, “Again and again, I make the statement that in theory anyone can become infected and spread the virus even after being fully vaccinated.” “Is the ambiguous message contributing to ambitious feelings about vaccination? Yes no questions.”

Messaging, Dr. of Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston. Abrar Karan said “quality is somewhat ancestral”. It is as if many experts do not trust people to understand that both vaccines make a huge difference and are unanswered questions.

As a result, the public message is in favor of alarmism: The vaccine is not a get-out-of-Kovid-free card!

In their own lives, medical experts – and, again, journalists – are cleared about vaccines. Several shots are happening as soon as they are offered one. They are urging their family and friends to do the same. But when they talk to national audiences, they deliver a message that comes in a very different way. It talks about risks, uncertainties, warnings and potential problems. This pre-existing anti-vaccine removes misinformation and anxiety.

No wonder its own community of experts (who are white, upper-income and liberal) Little doubt Black, Latino, working class and conservative communities compared to vaccines.

Over the next several weeks, Supply of available vaccines will increase. If a large number of Americans say there is no shot, however, many people will suffer unnecessarily. “It makes me sad,” Grabowski told me. “We created this amazing technology, and we could save so many lives.”

What should be the public message about vaccines? “They are fine. They are highly effective against critical illness. And the emerging evidence about infectiousness looks really good, ”Grabowski said. “If you have a vaccine and you are eligible, you should receive it.”

Virus development:

  • Confirmation of death of Kovid in US is fast More than 500,000 In the next few days.

  • In some states, authorities have expanded the supply of available vaccine doses Redistribution of unused shots From nursing homes and hospitals.

  • US will help finance global push Deliver vaccines For low and middle income countries.

Read one morning: To attend college with their daughters, an Iranian-American couple decided to return to the homeland they had left as children. Decision Grooming their lives.

Modern love: For this man, A thin line between able and loving.

From opinion: What is it? Cost of casteism, for all?

lives: Prince Marquee D, who released some commercially successful 1980s hip-hop albums as a member of the trio Fat Boys and helped absorb the genre’s pop culture, Died at 52.

Naming “Master Coster”, Lynn Stallmaster was the Oscar-winning casting director who helped build the careers of many other actors. He died at 93.

Fast-growing music, luxurious costumes, a sense of freedom: From Brooklyn to London and other places, Carnival has become an absolute joy to renew, resist and remember for Caribbean immigrants.

As singer Justin Sky, who usually participates in the West Indian American Day Parade in Brooklyn, he said: “Honestly, this is the one time of the year when I think no one seems to mind that you In what shape, size, color, you just come together and you just let it loose, and you just feel so confident within yourself. “

Because celebration This year has been canceled, many times Put together a project remembering the event And a description of its history. We are advising These shiny photos Blinged-out swimsuits and colorful plums from Caribbean Carnival worldwide.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

In Hong Kong, Foreign Tourists Are Replaced by a Local Variety

In Hong Kong, Foreign Tourists Are Replaced by a Local Variety Hong Kong - Of all the problems created by the epidemic, Sissi Wong did...

Seth Rogen Is All Fired Up

Seth Rogen Is All Fired Up Like so many people, he worked remotely, making calls about the film Project 9 to 5. Also, it's...

Triangulating Math, Mozart and ‘Moby-Dick’

Triangulating Math, Mozart and ‘Moby-Dick’ Sarah Hart, the first woman to hold England's prestigious Gresham Professorship of Geometry, explores the intersections of music, literature and...

‘I’ve Never Seen Anything Like This’: Chaos Strikes Global Shipping

‘I’ve Never Seen Anything Like This’: Chaos Strikes Global Shipping Off the coast of Los Angeles, more than two dozen container ships filled with exercise...